Far away long ago, Cinderella lives happily with her mother and father. Sadly, her mother dies and her father re-marries a cruel woman, who becomes Cinderella's stepmother. In Disney's version of Cinderella, the father passes away but in Brothers' Grimm version, the father is still alive. The stepmother has two daughters, Anastasia and Drizella. Since the sisters are just as cruel as their mother, the evil stepmother makes Cinderella the servant of the house out of envy. Meanwhile, across town, the King has invited every maiden in town to a ball for his son, the prince, so he can choose a wife. Throughout this fairy tale, Cinderella is a kind hearted person who is treated very harshly, still manages to remain pious and kind.
Watching this film as a child, you tend to not realize how Cinderella is treated and how it is actually bullying. You tend to recognize how the step sisters and stepmother are "evil", but never put it all together at a young age because you cannot fully comprehend. They envy Cinderella because of her beauty and they take advantage of her when her father passes away. In Maid in Manhattan, Marisa is recognized as a hotel maid and is looked down upon because she is not part of a higher social and money class. Just like Cinderella she is beautiful and a kind hearted person. They are treated awful by people who consider themselves higher than them. Both Cinderella and Marisa still manage to be themselves and obey all of their orders.
When Cinderella just wants to go to the ball, the animals help her put together a gorgeous dress because they believe she earned it and wants to help her in return. In Maid in Manhattan she has her ball experience and all of her co-workers help her because they believe she earned that one special night as well. Both of them have to have everything returned by a certain time. Caroline tries to get into Marisa's head by saying awful words that hurt Marisa. Caroline is jealous that Chris is interested in Marisa instead of her. She sees Marisa as a "maid" or someone who is not as good as her, which increases her jealousy. But Chris Marshall does not see it that way, he sees her for who she is. The evil step sisters are cruel towards Cinderella and do not treat her with respect but Cinderella treats them with respect. In this video it is a scene from Cinderella the movie, where it shows a true scene of bullying towards Cinderella. Cinderella comes downstairs to get into the carriage with her step sisters and stepmother, they yell at her through jealousy and ruin her dress. They physically and emotionally hurt Cinderella. The evil stepsisters are so jealous of how beautiful she is they have no issue ruining her dress right in front of her and the mother does nothing to stop it, she watches it happen. The sisters walk out of the house with their heads held up high because they think they ruined Cinderella's night and dress and made her feel upset. All Cinderella wanted was her one night to herself away from the work and mostly her stepmother and step sisters. That was when her fairy godmother appears and grants her an even better dress and makes her night perfect. This shows good things happen to good people.
Throughout the story, Cinderella, a kind and beautiful girl, is treated very harshly. At a young age you never put it together how evil the step sisters and stepmother really are, and the things they do to Cinderella are cruel towards her. Cinderella and Marisa manage to be the better person and not care what people think towards them, they are happy with who they are and where they come from. Cinderella and Maid in Manhattan show great things happen to good people, because they deserve it in the end.
Throughout the story, Cinderella, a kind and beautiful girl, is treated very harshly. At a young age you never put it together how evil the step sisters and stepmother really are, and the things they do to Cinderella are cruel towards her. Cinderella and Marisa manage to be the better person and not care what people think towards them, they are happy with who they are and where they come from. Cinderella and Maid in Manhattan show great things happen to good people, because they deserve it in the end.
Marissa and Cinderella are two women who are kind hearted and show the importance of being able to bounce back from being treated so poorly. In a way it shows the need of being the bigger person and looking for the silver lining in a bad situation, but it also can show children that it's better to take the poor treatment than to stand up for yourself. The compliance Cinderella shows to her stepmother and stepsisters and their every demand reduces her in a way as a person. In the opening scene of the Disney film, she sings of her dreams and how that is the only place they will really come true. It is only at the end of the film where she is given the chance to fulfill her dreams because she has gained status by marrying Prince Charming. Marissa on the other hand is a bit more defiant as she stands up to her mother after being fired from her job, claiming she will make her dreams come true. She is never able to confront her "evil stepsister" Caroline, but she is able to prove others wrong as she climbs the ladder in her new position at a hotel. However, she is placed in the spotlight because of her relationship with Chris. In both cases, it takes the man to give the woman more status. Their bullies essentially win by reducing them for the majority of the film, yet we as the audience are rooting for the women to come out on top, even if it takes a man to get them there...
ReplyDelete